U14 L3 Cup Match

I’ve been pondering something that happened in one of my games last Saturday 11th August.

An under 14 girls cup match (Team A vs Team B). My team was MA and CD, both young officials. It’s always fun working with a young team because it’s easier to spark enthusiasm and the right attitude with them than it is with older officials.

The video above is relevant for the situation that was bothering me and still is a little. In the 78th minute of play (2 minutes before the end of regular time), Team B was awarded a free kick 5 yards directly in front of the penalty area of their opponents and were down 3-2. The team needed the goal/opportunity to tie and move on the penalty shoot-outs or to score another to progress.

I ensured the wall was positioned at the required distance for the free kick and moved into position to watch the activity. Upon blowing the whistle, the kicker took the free kick and some sort of contact was made by a player in the wall. I suspected it struck a hand and that it was in an unnatural position but couldn’t make a call beyond that point. The ball then deflected off an attacking player and went out for a goal kick. The kick-taker appealed for a handball but I didn’t have a good enough position to watch for the situation so I declined and continued the game.

Free Kick Scenario

Having spoken with my AR MA at the end of the game who was across from the free kick, he said he suspected it strike a hand but not to classify it as deliberately handling the ball because where he thought the hand was and the speed of the ball. Either way positioning was poor on my part and I felt that the player might have had her hand away from the body above waist level. It was a game-changing decision to let it go but regardless, the lesson learnt is better positioning. I think recently my focus has been on the activity of a free kick more than the wall. Can’t let that happen!

FIFA’s instruction on the video above is a penalty and a red card for deliberately handling the ball to deny an obvious goalscoring opportunity. Almost opposite calls if that is what really happened. I really hope it wasn’t.


2 comments on “U14 L3 Cup Match

  1. Bill Bradley says:

    It’s fairly straightforward – if you don’t see the incident then you cannot call it. Therefore your decision was correct! As to positioning, given that you have the AR watching the offside I would have taken up a position slightly to the left and slightly back from where you were. Take a line parallel to the touch line from the edge of the area and parallel to the goal line from the free kick position and that would have been good. But you need to remember that it is pretty much impossible to see everything. You also should take into account that these are children and do not have the same level of bodily control as adults. Without seeing the incident I am sure it was not similar enough to the video for the result of the video to be relevant (taking into account relative strength etc), I am also pretty sure that the girl who handled the ball probably did so unintentionally. As for a red? How many 14 year old girls are likely to score from the best part of 25 yards away? Never ever send children off lightly – you may well turn someone off the beautiful game for ever!

    • larbitre says:

      That’s true! I didn’t call anything. My regret was that I didn’t see it so adjusting my position on free kicks will be crucial. My attention has been too strongly on the activity in the area recently than on the wall. Typically nothing major happens in the activity so I guess it might be all for naught or at least at this level. I should probably stay close to the wall.
      You’re definitely right about possibly turning them off from the beautiful game.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s